Separate an additional possibility from the required care
A breach of care is not proven by a wider viewing angle alone. Have a legal assessment made of whether a recognisable danger required heightened attention at all.
A wider viewing angle could have prevented the collision. Why OGH 8 Ob 125/24a says this alone does not establish a breach of care.
Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt
Your lawyer for ski and alpine accidents
Ski and alpine accidents are complex and emotional. One lawyer you know, from the first question to the courtroom. Strong practical background (former ski instructor, mountain rescuer and dog handler).
In larger cases, the work is handled as a team (lawyer, trainee lawyer, legal assistant). Court hearings and negotiations always remain a matter for the lead lawyer.
Even though the skier ahead has not breached the duty of care, a ski collision may be technically avoidable. In 8 Ob 125/24a of 5 December 2024, the Austrian Supreme Court confirmed this limit: the possibility of preventing a collision through heightened attention does not, by itself, create a duty to extend that attention.
Select the finding currently known. The result identifies the next issue to examine and does not decide liability.
You already know you want to send a request? Go directly to the contact form.
A breach of care is not proven by a wider viewing angle alone. Have a legal assessment made of whether a recognisable danger required heightened attention at all.
Heightened attention may be required by a recognisable danger. Information regarding the time the danger was visible and the response that would still have been possible should be preserved.
Traversing the slope is not constituted by long turns alone. Both complete skiing lines should be preserved and a legal assessment of the actual movement obtained.
Approaching from uphill, the claimant caught up with the defendant skier, who was making long turns and moving her head with the movement. With normal attention, the claimant could not be seen by the defendant one second or more before impact. No fault on the part of the defendant was found by the lower courts, and the Supreme Court rejected the claimant’s extraordinary appeal on points of law.
The technical finding was more specific: at a viewing angle of 52 degrees to the right rather than 45, the defendant could have seen the claimant. A deliberate further glance without turning her head would have sufficed. With a reaction 1.5 seconds before the collision, she could have avoided it via a left turn. These values describe the accident examined and represent no general thresholds for how far every skier must look.
Under the case law applied by the Supreme Court, no duty also to watch uphill generally exists for a skier who is not traversing the slope. Traversing the slope is not equivalent to making long turns. The skier ahead was entitled to trust that following skiers would respect her priority and leave enough room for her movements when overtaking.
The care required is clarified by the FIS rules. According to the Supreme Court, they are neither valid legal rules nor customary law. Therefore, a fault-based damages claim under § 1295 ABGB calls for an assessment of what conduct the law required in the particular situation. That question is not yet answered by an additional precaution that was technically conceivable.
Where a dangerous situation is recognisable, the decision requires attention extending beyond the normal field of vision. No such situation existed in the case decided. Therefore, the principle allowing reliance on others does not protect inattentive skiing despite a recognisable danger; it limits the demands made where compliance by following skiers may be relied on.
In another accident, the danger that was recognisable and the time at which it was recognisable must be established separately. That evidence cannot be replaced by a later calculation of a possible evasive movement. An actual traverse must also be assessed differently from the long turns considered here. The legal classification of the entire skiing line is not determined by a lateral point of impact alone.
For legal assessment, the positions of both skiers, their lines, and the sequence in time should be explained by technical findings. These findings should address separately when the other skier was visible with normal attention and what could only have been perceived with deliberately heightened attention. The response that would still have been possible can then be examined.
Accident sketches, original recordings, and witness contact details with accounts of what each person perceived should be preserved. The start of a movement, viewing direction, and first recognisable moment of danger matter. The facts on which an expert analysis relies should be identified by anyone presenting or responding to it. The legal question of whether additional observation was required remains distinct from the technical calculation.
Where injuries are serious and work is affected, substantial claims may be determined by the basis of liability. Different questions are addressed by medical records and evidence of lost earnings than by an accident reconstruction. A large loss does not replace proof of blameworthy conduct, any more than a finding that some different response would have prevented the accident replaces such proof.
Whether the established visibility and skiing conditions support a breach of care or whether the other side merely identifies an additional technical way to avoid the collision can be assessed with you by Mag. Christopher Angerer. The same facts must be fully disclosed when pursuing or defending a claim. The decision concerns the defendant skiing ahead in that case; it sets no fixed liability percentage for other slope collisions.
The 52 degrees mentioned in the decision constitute a finding about avoiding this accident. A general duty to use a particular viewing angle is not created by them. The actual skiing situation and a recognisable danger remain decisive.
Legally blameworthy conduct must be established for a fault-based claim. That the response was required in the situation at the time is not proved by the mere possibility of a different response.
Long turns are expressly distinguished from traversing the slope by the Supreme Court. The duty to observe when traversing must be assessed separately. Therefore, the established movement matters, rather than the label used by someone involved.
The sooner we secure the evidence, the better we can enforce your claim. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day.
Address
BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg
Phone
+43 660 2407152