SKIRECHT
Slope accidents

Claiming too much for pain and suffering: costs in a ski accident lawsuit

When § 43(2) ZPO allows recovery of costs despite a lower award, and how excessive claims, other heads of damage and contributory fault affect the result.

Your personal attorney

Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt

Your lawyer for ski and alpine accidents

Ski and alpine accidents are complex and emotional. One lawyer you know, from the first question to the courtroom. Strong practical background (former ski instructor, mountain rescuer and dog handler).

In larger cases, the work is handled as a team (lawyer, trainee lawyer, legal assistant). Court hearings and negotiations always remain a matter for the lead lawyer.

26 October 2026 · Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt

A corresponding share of the opposing party’s costs does not automatically fall on you following a lower award for pain and suffering after a ski accident. Uncertainty in an expert or judicial assessment can be accommodated by § 43(2) ZPO. An obviously excessive claim is not protected by the exception. Before suing, have the defensible amount, the other heads of damage, and the basis for recovering costs reviewed together.

Before bringing proceedings

Which uncertainty affects the amount you intend to claim?

Choose the unresolved issue. The result identifies the next point to review and does not calculate a costs ratio.

Would you like to send an enquiry? Go directly to the contact form.

01 Question 1

Why might part of the action be dismissed?

Procedure status

The next points to check.

01

Review a defensible assessment and costs basis.

Review medical findings, comparable cases and previous payments. Have obvious overclaiming and recovery based on the successful amount assessed.

02

Assess each head of damage separately.

Allocate evidence and the possible reason for dismissal to each item. The pain-and-suffering privilege does not protect a mixed action as a whole.

03

Calculate liability risk as well.

Distinguish uncertainty about amount from your contribution to the accident or unproven opposing liability. The costs scenarios must consider both.

Why you must quantify pain and suffering before the court expert reports

Specific relief under § 226 ZPO is required for a payment action. You must therefore state an amount and identify the supporting facts and evidence, although the court expert’s report often arrives only during the proceedings. With serious injuries, permanent consequences, the future course of pain and psychological distress can make assessment particularly difficult. Reasons supporting the amount sought are not replaced by an arbitrary safety margin.

Compensation for pain and suffering appropriate to the circumstances is provided for by § 1325 ABGB. While medical expert evidence supplies a foundation, the task of legal assessment remains the court’s. Under the statutory conditions in § 273 ZPO, the court may determine the amount according to its own assessment. In 2 Ob 63/11w of 14.07.2011, the overall effects of injury rather than fixed daily rates were stressed by the Austrian Supreme Court. The case concerned a road accident, and this general assessment principle also matters for ski accident damage.

When a lower award does not produce a corresponding reduction in costs recovery

§ 43(1) ZPO generally provides for costs to be set off or divided proportionately where each party partly succeeds and partly loses, while Subsection 2 contains exceptions. The important situation for pain and suffering is where the amount depends on judicial discretion or determination by experts; the court may then award full recovery of costs despite partial dismissal. This assessment exception does not require the unsuccessful part to be merely minor, and it must be distinguished from the other statutory exception for a relatively minor unsuccessful part that has caused no particular additional costs.

The limit: a recognisably and obviously excessive demand

The costs privilege cannot be relied upon by a claimant seeking an obviously excessive amount merely because the court assesses the amount. This is stated by the Supreme Court in legal proposition RS0035993. The question remains whether reasonable considerations concerning the injury and relevant case law still support the claim. No reliable safe harbour is offered by a fixed percentage threshold. The amount claimed must be made intelligible by medical findings, the course of pain, and comparable decisions.

The ratio between the remaining amount finally claimed and the remaining amount awarded can also mislead. When reviewing excessiveness in 2 Ob 242/09s of 28.01.2010, the Supreme Court considered the total pain-and-suffering demand, including earlier proceedings and partial payments. Therefore, limited success in the final proceedings did not by itself establish disqualifying overclaiming. To include previous payments and awards in the overall schedule is the practical lesson from this road accident decision. No general permission to claim arbitrarily high sums is provided by it.

Full recovery of costs generally uses a lower assessment basis

The costs privilege does not transform the excessive amount claimed into an unreduced basis for calculating costs. Under the case law, full costs recovery is generally based on the amount successfully recovered where there is no obvious overclaiming. In 2 Ob 242/09s, the recoverable court lump-sum fee was also assessed on that basis. You may therefore retain some expenditure even where a defensible overestimate of pain and suffering does not itself lead to proportionate liability for opposing costs. The court’s costs decision also does not automatically cover every agreed fee or actual expense. Individual assessment is required for appeals and separate stages of proceedings.

Assess invoices, lost earnings and liability disputes separately

A ski accident action often combines pain and suffering with treatment costs, care expenses or lost earnings. For items already capable of quantification, the amount, entitlement and connection with the accident must be established separately. No protection from the pain-and-suffering costs privilege is received by an unfounded invoice. Judicial or expert assessment may also be required for other items: in 2 Ob 63/11w, care costs assessed under § 273 ZPO alongside pain and suffering were considered by the Supreme Court. The legal treatment therefore depends on the particular item and the reason for dismissing it.

A dispute regarding liability or contributory fault also remains separate. Should your claim be reduced due to your contribution to the accident, or should the opposing party’s responsibility fail to be established, this pertains to the basis of liability. The assessment exception does not eliminate that costs risk. Where several items are claimed, the correct assessment bases and remaining success ratios must therefore be combined. For that review, merely comparing the total claim with the total payment awarded is often insufficient.

The documents needed for a sound litigation costs strategy

Before the claim is quantified, medical findings, operation records, a medical prognosis, documented limitations, and a complete schedule of damage should be brought together. The amount sought, the evidence, and all previous payments should be allocated to each item. This enables your lawyer to review a defensible pain-and-suffering amount and the costs consequences of a lower assessment, contributory fault, or failure of individual items. If a court expert’s report changes the foundation, the relief sought, procedural stages, and costs calculation need to be aligned again. Reducing the claim does not automatically remove costs consequences already incurred.

§ 43 Abs. 1 ZPO, § 43 Abs. 2 ZPO. OGH 2 Ob 63/11w. OGH 2 Ob 242/09s.

Your questions

Questions about costs when pain and suffering is overestimated

Do I automatically pay opposing costs if the court awards less? +

The costs question is not settled by a lower award alone. On the relevant lower basis, § 43(2) ZPO may allow full costs recovery for defensibly overestimated pain and suffering. Additional review is required for obvious overclaiming, liability disputes, and other dismissed items.

May I seek a particularly high amount as a precaution? +

Intelligible support by the injuries and legal assessment must be provided for the amount sought. The costs privilege is excluded by a recognisably and obviously excessive demand. No generally safe percentage threshold is supplied by the case law.

Does the exception also protect unsuccessful treatment-cost claims? +

Separate assessment is required for each item. If, for example, proof of an invoice or its connection with the accident is missing, uncertainty in assessing pain and suffering does not by itself absorb that failure. However, a separate judicial assessment of another item may be relevant.

Does full recovery of costs reimburse all my expenditure? +

The amount successfully recovered generally serves as the basis for calculating costs recovery. Separate review is required to determine whether particular expenses were necessary and to what extent they are recoverable. A difference from the fee agreed with your lawyer may also remain payable by you.

Related litigation questions

Related litigation questions

Had an accident?

The sooner we secure the evidence, the better we can enforce your claim. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day.

Contact

A direct line to the firm.

Address

BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg