Assess the personal claim separately
A private restaurant descent with no internal connection to company obligations does not support attribution under § 1313a ABGB. Have the personal claim against the employee assessed separately.
Private descent or work assignment: When a cableway company may be liable for an employee’s ski accident under § 1313a ABGB in Austria.
Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt
Your lawyer for ski and alpine accidents
Ski and alpine accidents are complex and emotional. One lawyer you know, from the first question to the courtroom. Strong practical background (former ski instructor, mountain rescuer and dog handler).
In larger cases, the work is handled as a team (lawyer, trainee lawyer, legal assistant). Court hearings and negotiations always remain a matter for the lead lawyer.
Employment alone does not make the employer liable under § 1313a ABGB when a lift employee collides with a guest while skiing privately during a lunch break. An internal connection with an obligation the company has undertaken towards the guest must exist for the descent. This distinction was confirmed by the Austrian Supreme Court in 1 Ob 127/25w of 11 November 2025.
A separate legal assessment is therefore required to choose the defendant for seriously injured winter sports participants. Taken together, established employee misconduct and a purchased ski pass are insufficient for a successful claim against the cableway company. In particular, the purpose of the specific descent must be established.
Select the situation you know. The result identifies the next assessment and does not determine liability.
You already know you want to send a request? Go directly to the contact form.
A private restaurant descent with no internal connection to company obligations does not support attribution under § 1313a ABGB. Have the personal claim against the employee assessed separately.
A work assignment may establish the internal connection with contractual performance. Preserve the assignment and route; company liability requires assessment of all applicable conditions.
Employee status alone does not decide attribution. Preserve statements and existing records about tasks, instructions and destination before having company liability assessed.
Under § 1313a ABGB, the person using others to perform an obligation bears liability for their fault as for their own. A performance assistant is the term used to describe such an employee. Attribution depends on the specific performance obligations and duties of protection and care that the company has undertaken towards its contracting partner.
Therefore, the question is answered only in part by employment by the lift operator. What matters is whether the employee acted within the assigned tasks and whether an internal functional connection with contractual performance existed. For that reason alone, damage caused merely on the occasion of work does not fall within this attribution.
In the decided case, a collision between a skier and a snowboarder resulted in injury to the snowboarder. The skier served as an attendant at a drag lift, and the injured party had purchased a multi-day ski pass. The proceedings concerned a claim for 251.491,35 euros plus ancillary claims and declaratory relief. This amount was claimed, not awarded as compensation.
It was established by the findings that the employee was skiing to a restaurant to spend his lunch break there. The descent was unrelated to piste safety, cableway operations, or rescuing accident victims. Operational instructions governing the break were neither alleged nor established. The claim against the cableway company was dismissed by the lower courts, and the Supreme Court rejected the extraordinary appeal against that dismissal for lack of a substantial legal question.
The Supreme Court distinguished the private descent from an earlier case in which a lift attendant was required to inspect the drag-lift track and subsequently return to the boarding point. The performance of that task necessitated his use of the piste where the accident occurred. Such necessary travel within assigned duties differs from a freely arranged lunch break.
Therefore, calling the period a break is no more conclusive by itself than is proximity to the lift station or the time of day. Examination is required of the specific assignment and the obligations undertaken by the company. Even where a descent serves a work purpose, separate assessment is still required for fault and its causal connection with the damage.
For legal assessment, the ski pass and contractual documents, the accident report, and information regarding the employee’s duties should be brought together. The destination, starting point, and route are material, as is the identity of the person who assigned the specific task to the employee. Witnesses or existing operational records may assist in distinguishing an alleged inspection or return journey from a private restaurant descent.
What was said immediately after the accident and who provided the information must be recorded. While a duty roster may explain the employee’s presence, it does not by itself establish an assignment for this descent. Conversely, a general statement by the company that the employee was on a break should be checked against the specific events.
In 1 Ob 127/25w, a partial interlocutory judgment that was final on that issue had already established the employee’s misconduct. That judgment did not supply the missing connection with performance of the company’s obligations. Dismissal against the company therefore does not mean that a personal claim against the person who caused the accident is also excluded.
Before a claim is brought or settled, the legal basis must be assessed separately against each potential defendant. Mag. Christopher Angerer examines whether the established facts support attribution to the cableway company and which claims against the employee should be pursued. The choice of defendant should rest on the specific task and descent.
The contractual relationship may be established by a ski pass. For § 1313a ABGB, an internal connection between the harmful conduct and the performance of the assumed obligations is also decisive. In the decided case, this connection was missing for the private restaurant descent.
The specific activity matters. A private descent with no operational instructions alleged or established was assessed by the Supreme Court. Where an assignment relates to assumed duties towards customers, separate assessment on those facts is required for attribution.
The monetary claim amounted to 251.491,35 euros and was accompanied by a claim for declaratory relief. It was not an award. The extraordinary appeal concerned the dismissal of the claim against the cableway company, and that appeal was rejected.
The sooner we secure the evidence, the better we can enforce your claim. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day.
Address
BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg
Phone
+43 660 2407152